Celebrity Beauty

It’s perfect for effortless siren eyes.

Black eyeliner has had its day.

In the early 2000s,people discovered tightliningand made it their personality (think Avril Lavigne).

Hailey Bieber just cosigned the brown eyeliner trend.

But the game is changing.

First came thebrown mascara trend, which delivered a more natural look.

More recently, some have beeneschewing mascara completely.

hailey bieber brown eyeliner

So mascara is out, and it seems only natural that eyeliner trends are evolving too.

And Hailey Bieber just endorsed the latter.

Her product of choice?

brown eyeliner

TheMake Up Forever Artist Color Pencil.

A super versatile product, it provides a softer, undone but intentional look, he tells Bustle.

Brown eyeliner can give you definition without the intensity of black, which can look overdone or aging.

Artist Color Pencil in Anywhere Caffeine

Its versatile enough for a clean liner look, or to smudge out for a more undone aesthetic.

And Bieber clearly feels the same.

Satin Kajal Liner in Cocoa

Precision Color Pencil in Barna

Eye Love You Eye Pencil in Kôhl Brun

No.1 Pencil in Frame

Slim Eye Pencil in Dark Brown